Muslims Hear Echoes of Jim Crow in Current Furor
By Imam Zaid Shakir · September 15, 2010
Reprint: Sept. 10, 2010 by Adelle M. Banks
WASHINGTON (RNS) Imam Mahdi Bray is feeling a sense of deja vu these days, with threats and attacks on Muslims reviving memories of his younger days working and marching alongside civil rights activists.
"For me and for America, these types of things have happened over and over again," said Bray, of the Muslim American Society.
He and other African-American Muslim leaders say the recent verbal and physical attacks against Muslims because of their faith are painful reminders of past discrimination felt by blacks because of their skin color.
Threats to burn Qurans recall the bombings of black churches, they say, and anti-Muslim activist Pamela Geller's crusade against the proposed Park51 Islamic cultural center near Ground Zero summons memories of Bull Connor's orders to aim fire hoses at civil rights marchers in Alabama.
"When people are talking about exclusionary zones where Muslims cannot build houses of worship or cannot freely assemble, then it evokes memories of those exclusionary politics and exclusionary laws African-Americans had to deal with," said Imam Zaid Shakir, a professor at Zaytuna College, the nation's first Muslim college, in Berkeley, Calif.
The Coalition of African American Muslims, saying their voices had been missing from the debate around Park51, declared recently that they would not "silently accept a return to Jim Crow exclusionary practices and policies that relegate either ourselves or our coreligionists ... to second-class citizenry."
The coalition includes leaders such as Nation of Islam leader Minister Louis Farrakhan and Asma Hanif, the founder of an organization that helps homeless Muslim women.
Hanif sees parallels in how all black people -- "it didn't matter if you had one drop of black blood" -- were treated in the 1960s when she was a teenager in a small town in North Carolina. "Now it doesn't matter what type of Muslim you are, they are treating you the exact same way," said Hanif, executive director of Baltimore-based Muslimat Al-Nisaa.
Lawrence Mamiya, a professor of religion and Africana studies at Vassar College, said there are parallels between the treatment of blacks during the civil rights movement and the backlash over Park51, but there are differences, too. "The civil rights movement was dealing with a system of legal segregation and here, at least Muslims do have the freedom of religion, "said Mamiya, an expert on African-American Muslims. "But in terms of the kind of opposition they're meeting, certainly the parallels are there."
Akbar Muhammad, a retired international representative for the Nation of Islam, faults ignorance about Muslims and the Quran for the recent wave of anti-Muslim bigotry, just as lack of understanding resulted in racially based bigotry decades ago.
"They thought we were either inferior or ... that we deserved to be relegated to a corner or lynched," he said. "Now, Muslims are profiled as black people are profiled."
Aminah McCloud, professor of Islamic studies at DePaul University in Chicago, estimates that at least 40 percent of leaders of predominantly black mosques were active in the civil rights movement or were born soon after. She hopes their perspective, and experience, can be a "reflective voice" in the current controversies. "It draws people's attention away from the hysterics and back to the history of who we are in this country ... a remembrance of how many Americans, white and black, brown and of all religious traditions, have worked so hard to make multiculturalism, multireligious existence work," she said.
Copyright 2010 Religion News Service. All rights reserved. No part of this transmission may be distributed or reproduced without written permission.
For more info: National Press Club conference held in Washington D.C.on 9/2/10: http://finalcallnation.edgeboss.net/wmedia/finalcallnation/finalcall_nationofislam/caam_press_conf09-02-2010.wvx
Comments (15)
OfeliaMadden33
September 17, 2010
Buildings are not very cheap and not everyone can buy it. However, mortgage loans was invented to help people in such hard situations.
RojasJudy21
September 18, 2010
All people deserve good life time and personal loans or just commercial loan will make it better. Because people's freedom is grounded on money state.
paris12
September 21, 2010
Thanks for this great post. . :) condos for sale in orlando
Ravij Omar - tesolcourse
September 24, 2010
In some point, Muslims are imaged as violent people. The same is true in almost every where. However, once you get to know one, one will realize that this common notion is not true.
kristel12
September 27, 2010
great forum. . . :)
Gregory Abdur Rahman
October 4, 2010
as salaam alaikum, Imam Zaid, you are one of the smartest Imams I know. You came to Miami and gave a khutbah and I didn't know a thing about you, but just from the khutbah, I knew you were a sharp sharp Muslim, who knows the sources. So today I am so hurt. When did Louis Farrakhan become a Muslim? Most people I know and by my limited understanding of the definition, in its most liberal interpretation, which I read from Dr. Jackson, excludes Minister Farrakhan from sitting with Muslims and calling himself a Muslim. I really don't even like associating with known racist and supremacist because black racism harms no one, improves no one and is only an excuse for the far more devastating white racism. As Muslims, I thought that we say that Allah, His Book and His messenger are the answer. If someone rejects the book and the Sunnah, then how as a Muslim can you solve problems with someone who not only rejects, but lies and creates confusion about God's ultimate solution to all humanity? It is a folly of youth that you can get with "your people," based on race and move things. As we get older, we learn that help comes from the far corner sometimes. I have no problem with people not choosing Islam. We have a big problem. Right now there are competing ideas about Islam in the Muslim world. Some say, if you live in the West, your blood is halaal. Other nuts say, "the black man is god." And the white non Muslims say, we don't deserve equal rights after they put the nuts on tv hour after hour, convincing the entire world that Islam is built on deviant ideas. The Haqq of Allah, is what will dominate and control things in the end. And as Muslims our duty is to stand in that, not stand with kooks. Imam you know these things....so why do you think embracing black racists will help Islam??????
Gregory Abdur Rahman
October 6, 2010
as salaam alaikum, what end is served by Imam Zaid forming a partnership with Louis Farrakhan????
LynetteShepherd19
February 19, 2011
It is well known that cash makes people disembarrass. But how to act if one does not have cash? The one way only is to receive the credit loans and just secured loan.
Bobs
June 19, 2011
Fell out of bed felenig down. This has brightened my day!
Alexa
February 10, 2012
Superior web page. I like your writing comments system. I am sorry for the off-topic write-up, yet I had been really fascinated with Djokovic's play in the final of the Aussie OPen this yr. The guy is just unrivaled. He exhibited he had been as strong as stainlesss steel. Simply consider about he he could defeat Nadal who had been so stimulated to win and really was so energized up during the fifth set. I'm beginning to consider that Djokovic is performing some faith based work to bring some aids on his side that really help him secure these matches against the best players in the globe buy essay university . What's your opinion about Rafa's game?
Writing service
February 11, 2012
That's some very good information written right here. I thank you for excellent information. I 'm writing a research paper regarding state policies and your web page aided a lot. I am a higher education university student and if you are in a absence of time I endorse to get support pertaining to Best Writing Site . Cheers!
Motivation to lose weight
April 7, 2012
jNDzme Muchos Gracias for your article.Really thank you! Will read on...
Motivation to lose weight
April 7, 2012
Ob3AWH A round of applause for your article post.Much thanks again. Want more.
Dissertation Help
April 15, 2012
Very good post. Terrific tips distributed. Adore your web site. dissertation writing help All the best !.
TimurDumb
April 17, 2012
I need to give thanks to you with regards to your blog page. You have heaps of interesting material and so the site is interesting. I'm a university student in Colorado and I have got an significant term paper due immediately. I'm caught up as well as currently have writers block now as I am researching. Simply need anyone to assist me modify the free essay I stumbled upon online macbeth, internal conflicts essay . That document satisfies my requirements however is authored in a bad manner and there are sentence structure mistakes. Do you think I would proceed? Now i'm simply just in need of aid, thus any tip could be good.
More Notes
On The Passing of Lindsey Graham
Imam Zaid Shakir · July 12, 2026
“It is not the least ironic that Lindsey Graham should pass away at a time the country is celebrating its 250th anniversary. Graham represented the genocidal impulse that has stained American history. As Americans we do not like discussing the fact…
Note
The American/Israeli War on Iran: Part One
Imam Zaid Shakir · April 22, 2026
The savage, unprovoked American/Israeli attack on Iran illustrates an old play, as far as the American side is concerned. It is amazing that the same script is rolled out for each violent, imperialist episode, yet there are still people who line up…
Note
Imam Jamil, Imam Talib: Two Mountains
Imam Zaid Shakir · January 11, 2026
Owing to a very difficult and challenging couple of months, I was unable to sit down and share my thoughts on the passing of two giants who impacted me and many others in profound ways. Those two giants are Imam Jamil al-Amin and Imam Talib Abdul…
Note