Speaking of Civility...
By Imam Zaid Shakir · January 21, 2011
America is understandably shaken by the attempted assassination of Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords. That mindless assault claimed the lives of six individuals, including a promising nine-year-old child and a sitting federal judge. In the aftermath of that act there has been a call from many sides, including the President, for greater civility in the public political discourse. One of the reasons for that call has been the perception, held by some, that Gifford's assailant was a product of the climate of vitriolic political speech that has been growing in this country. If that is true or not we may never know. However, the mean-spirited tone and the increasingly nasty nature of our political discourse in undeniable.
Like most Americans, I welcome the call for increased civility in our political discourse. However, I question its sincerity. My cynicism is based on the fact that in recent years no group has been exposed to the level of vitriolic, defamatory, demeaning and threatening speech than America's Muslim community. Yet in the discussion of "toning down the rhetoric" there has been no mention of the situation the Muslim community faces in this regard.
It is well known, as has been stated by the noted linguist and political analyst, Noam Chomsky, and others, that anti-Muslim bigotry is the last acceptable bastion of unmitigated, uncensored hate speech in this country. Every day, Muslims must listen to our Prophet, peace upon him, defamed and slandered, our religion ridiculed, our lives threatened, and a growing array of “Muslim jokes,” many with nasty, racist undertones. Mainstream politicians like Tom Tancredo have called for the nuclear bombing of our holy city. On the website of the noted African American conservative and former senatorial candidate, Alan Keyes, is an article calling for genocide against Muslims. Intellectuals like Sam Harris make twisted arguments calling for our extermination, and armies of bloggers fill the internet with unspeakable hate-filled diatribes against our religion, leaders and organizations.
As a result of the climate of hate that has been generated around the uncivilized anti-Islamic discourse there are escalating attacks against Muslims, our homes and houses of worship. Yet the call for greater civility in our public discourse somehow misses us. Many feel we simply do not matter in the political calculation because our weak and fragmented community poses no threat to the political or economic interests of those engaging in our defamation. Yet somehow we are said to threaten, in the view of some, the very existence of this country.
This is a sad and even tragic situation that those who stand idly by and allow this climate of anti-Muslim hatred to grow, unabated, will soon come to regret. Those individuals and groups descending into the abyss of anti-Muslim hatred represent a dark force, which may have been unleashed against Muslims, but once that force reaches full strength it loses its ability to discriminate, for its roots lay not in reason, but in violent, inflamed passion. That force becomes like a powerful hurricane whose winds destroy all in its path. Similarly, like those late summer storms that feed on hot air, the path of hate-filled masses is difficult to predict. It may be currently bearing down on Muslims, yet it can suddenly change course and head off wildly in another unforeseen direction.
The best way to prevent that storm is to stop it before it gains strength. Any call for increased civility in America has to include, or even start with greater civility in the discourse around Islam and Muslims. If that discourse is excluded from the conversation on civility then everyone should start boarding up their windows now, because a monstrous storm will soon hit shore.
Comments (43)
Zaynab
January 22, 2011
Sobering thoughts, Imam Zaid. Thank you for this reminder. Sadly, we are not even on the map, unless someone wants to bash us.
Gregory Abdur Rahman
January 23, 2011
as salaam alaikum, Imam many of us love you for the brains and the ability to speak on things that Allah has given you. You are very right. I recently saw an African American website that said this violence is inherent to the nature of America as it is presently structured. So the negative turn this can take probably will happen, especially for us Muslims. It only when a huge tragedy comes that people slow down and then back up and that is only for a minute. The civil rights struggle was so bloody and involved so much suffering, yet America continues to discriminate against black people. We Muslims are even a smaller group with less media favoring our cause. In the back of their minds, they believe they can change us. They know they can't change the color of your skin, but Islam can only be maintained in our hearts and minds. So the questions you raise are long term. If we Muslims collapse and run from Islam, then they will feel justified and rightly so. It will only be after second and third generations from where we are, when those people are still fighting in word and deed for Allah and Prophet Muhammad, will our struggle gain any legitimacy in their eyes. They see immigrants and blacks bow before the alter that is America every day and their experience teaches them to expect the same for us. May Allah protect us and extend our faith in all directions no matter where we are.... Ameen Peace and blessings be upon the messenger of Allah.
Gregory Abdur Rahman
January 24, 2011
as salaam alaikum, Imam many of us love you for the brains and the ability to speak on things that Allah has given you. You are very right. I recently saw an African American website that said this violence is inherent to the nature of America as it is presently structured. So the negative turn this can take probably will happen, especially for us Muslims. It is only when a huge tragedy comes that people slow down and then back up from the hateful mindsets and that is only for a minute. The civil rights struggle was so bloody and involved so much suffering, yet America continues to discriminate against black people. We Muslims are an even a smaller group with less media favoring our cause. In the back of their minds, they believe they can change us. They know they can't change the color of your skin, but Islam can only be maintained in our hearts and minds. So the questions you raise are long term. If we Muslims collapse and run from Islam, then they will feel justified in their persecutions and rightly so. It will only be after our second and third generations from where we are, when those people, 100 years from now, are still fighting in word and deed for Allah and Prophet Muhammad, will our struggle gain any legitimacy in their eyes. For the last 100 years, they have seen immigrants and blacks bow before the alter that is America every day and their experience teaches them to expect the same from us. May Allah protect us and extend our faith in all directions no matter where we are.... Ameen Peace and blessings be upon the messenger of Allah.
aziz
January 26, 2011
timbangan digital says : Subhanallah ..Keep Istiqomah
Raynes
April 26, 2011
Kudos to you! I hadn't tohghut of that!
low cost car insurance
July 1, 2011
Good
affordable car insurance
July 7, 2011
Thank you for the sensible critique. Me & my neighbor were just preparing to do some research about this. We got a grab a book from our local library but I think I learned more from this post. I'm very glad to see such excellent info being shared freely out there. affordable auto insurance low cost auto insurance
unwinnyUtibia
July 15, 2011
I want to show my love for your kind-heartedness supporting people that should have guidance on this area of interest. Your special dedication to getting the message all-around appeared to be exceedingly effective and has in every case permitted somebody like me to reach their endeavors. Your interesting recommendations means a whole lot to me and substantially more to my fellow workers. Best wishes; from all of us. prezenty firmowe
Asybrifs
July 18, 2011
I am very grateful to you for the information. ubezpieczenie ADAC
Cegmetillinna
July 19, 2011
I
Reibriccribra
July 19, 2011
Remember it once and for all! projekty
projektowanie
July 19, 2011
I appreciate, cause I found just what I was looking for. You have ended my 4 day long hunt! God Bless you man. Have a nice day. Bye Projektowanie wnętrz
elewacjakamienna
July 21, 2011
I consider, that you are not right. Write to me in PM, we will communicate. schody marmurowe: blaty kuchenne
blatygranitowe
July 21, 2011
It agree, it is an excellent idea łazienka marmur: granit
Asybrifs
July 21, 2011
It is remarkable, very good piece ubezpieczenia
oradierry
July 23, 2011
You have hit the mark. Thought excellent, I support. pogotowie stomatologiczne łódź
Agobidiok
July 26, 2011
It is remarkable, very amusing message tani ebook
triegoTribete
July 30, 2011
I apologise, but, in my opinion, you commit an error. I can prove it. Write to me in PM, we will communicate. Free List of Fat Burning Foods
plushipummoni
August 14, 2011
I think, that you commit an error. I can defend the position. Write to me in PM, we will communicate. kowalstwo artystyczne
Reibriccribra
August 14, 2011
What words... super, an excellent idea projekty domów jednorodzinnych
biokeCymnmymn
August 14, 2011
You are not right. I am assured. I can defend the position. Write to me in PM, we will talk. powierzchnie biurowe łódź
LapanameLic
August 15, 2011
I must get across my respect for your kind-heartedness giving support to individuals that require guidance on that area of interest. Your very own commitment to getting the solution along came to be surprisingly good and have in most cases allowed ladies just like me to realize their desired goals. Your personal warm and helpful advice means a great deal a person like me and even further to my mates. Regards; from all of us. blaty granitowe
Utewmeve
August 15, 2011
In it something is also to me it seems it is excellent idea. I agree with you. dieta odchudzająca dieta białkowa dieta warszawa
free-ipad
October 6, 2011
www.newislamicdirections.com rss feed bookmarked ! free ipad
car insurance rates
October 18, 2011
Someone necessarily assist to make significantly articles I would state. That is the very first time I frequented your website page and to this point? I amazed with the research you made to make this particular put up amazing. Excellent activity! auto insurance rates
xbox-giveaway
November 4, 2011
That's why i have bookmarked www.newislamicdirections.com xbox360 giveaway
mw3-giveaway
November 8, 2011
www.newislamicdirections.com is amazing, good work! Free Modern Warfare 3
htc-hd7
November 10, 2011
I miss www.newislamicdirections.com !!! Today i come back here HTC HD7 giveaway
samsung-vibrant-giveaway
December 1, 2011
My number 1 site now - www.newislamicdirections.com samsung galaxy s giveaway
motorola-xoom
December 6, 2011
www.newislamicdirections.com is my number one site motorola xoom
betathome-italia
December 20, 2011
www.newislamicdirections.com is my favorite place now! bet at home italia
Peerfly
December 25, 2011
I come back to www.newislamicdirections.com every single day!! cpa network
Custom Essays
January 17, 2012
Heya ! I actually enjoy the sense and judgement of the actual writer. Excellent to see such principles discussed on the world wide web. You certainly ought to stimulate visitor conversation and debate Buy A Paper Online . Keep up the good job!
custom research papers
January 31, 2012
Very good information. Many thanks for your website. Merely a idea. I'm not really promoting Google the slightest bit, however i have noticed that you're not utilizing Google Analytics on your site. That could be a good way to transform your site and profit from it in a far better way. It really enables to monitor visits and see what specific written content is most popular. I endorse it. Yet another good software system for that function is PIWIK which is an open source totally free program that you simply set up on your internet hosting account Term Paper Writing Service
Motivation to lose weight
April 7, 2012
HOGJni Muchos Gracias for your post.
Motivation to lose weight
April 8, 2012
93fvkb I think this is a real great article post.Much thanks again. Really Cool.
Dissertation Coaching
April 16, 2012
Very good article. Terrific thoughts distributed. Like your web page. hire dissertation writer Enjoy.
TimurDumb
April 17, 2012
I wish to thank you for your blog page. You've lots of unique information hence the website is extremely helpful. I'm a college student in Cali and I have an important school assignment due now. I am just tangled and get writers block for the time being as I am studying. Just need a person to guide me modify the cost-free essay I stumbled upon on line cloning essay . That document fits my personal prerequisites nevertheless is composed in an undesirable manner and there are sentence structure problems. Do you reckon I ought to proceed? I am simply eager for support, thus any idea would be terrific.
euro 2012 zaklady bukmacherskie
May 18, 2012
www.newislamicdirections.com is absolute awsome bukmacher euro 2012
cackduccadly
June 14, 2012
I recommend to you to look a site, with a large quantity of articles on a theme interesting you. http://www.yacsports.us/Guestbook/index.php
wyszukiwarka mp3
July 27, 2012
Nice|Good} blog! Only dilemma is i’m running Firefox on Debian, and the site is searching slightly.. weird! Perhaps you may want to test it to see for yourself.
refluks
July 28, 2012
Spot on with this write-up, I actually assume this website needs way more consideration. I’ll most likely be again to read rather more, thanks for that info.
cnochcfb
November 14, 2012
san diego chargers jersey san diego chargers jerseys chargers jersey
More Notes
On The Passing of Lindsey Graham
Imam Zaid Shakir · July 12, 2026
“It is not the least ironic that Lindsey Graham should pass away at a time the country is celebrating its 250th anniversary. Graham represented the genocidal impulse that has stained American history. As Americans we do not like discussing the fact…
Note
The American/Israeli War on Iran: Part One
Imam Zaid Shakir · April 22, 2026
The savage, unprovoked American/Israeli attack on Iran illustrates an old play, as far as the American side is concerned. It is amazing that the same script is rolled out for each violent, imperialist episode, yet there are still people who line up…
Note
Imam Jamil, Imam Talib: Two Mountains
Imam Zaid Shakir · January 11, 2026
Owing to a very difficult and challenging couple of months, I was unable to sit down and share my thoughts on the passing of two giants who impacted me and many others in profound ways. Those two giants are Imam Jamil al-Amin and Imam Talib Abdul…
Note