Why They Want To Do Us Harm
By Imam Zaid Shakir · April 11, 2010
This essay is the unedited version of a response Imam Zaid wrote to a question posed by Helen Thomas to the White House press corps, "Why do they want to do us harm?" Thomas never got an answer so "In These Times" posed the question to several respondents. The edited version along with other responses can be viewed at:
http://www.inthesetimes.com/article/5712/why_do_they_want_to_do_us_harm_part_one/
To a large extent, “they” are simply a microcosmic mirror image of the extremist violence perpetrated by a hegemonic state dominated by elites that have reserved the right to use high-tech military machinery to systematically decimate countries, rip apart their social fabrics and directly or indirectly kill hundreds of thousands of people as has happened in Iraq.
In that country, “they” might be the relative of someone who died of typhoid or diarrhea from drinking sewage-contaminated water because “we” thought it a noble stratagem of war to destroy Iraq’s sanitation system during the 1991 Desert Storm operation. “they” might be someone whose home was blown away during the “Shock and Awe” campaign that inaugurated the current war in March, 2003. Maybe “they” never recovered from the shock and have been transformed by insensitive bombs into insensitive killers. Maybe “they” were brutalized and humiliated at Abu Ghraib. Maybe “they” know of Abeer Hamza al-Janabi, the 14 year-old Iraqi girl who was gang raped by a company of American soldiers, who proceeded to murder her and her entire family, including her 6-year old sister, Hadeel, and then burn their bodies to hide the evidence of their heinous crime.
Perhaps “they” are from Afghanistan, and want to do us harm for the reasons mentioned above. Maybe the callousness “they” display towards life is a reflection of the callousness we displayed when we built the “Jihad” movement to repel the Soviet invaders of that land during the 1980s, and after accomplishing that mission walked away leaving the country to endure almost a decade of murderous anarchy that culminated in the rise of the Taliban and Osama bin Laden. Perhaps the alienation “they” display is a pathetic parody of the Mujahideen “we” created.
Maybe “they” are not from Iraq or Afghanistan. Maybe “they” are rotting in a slum in Casablanca or Cairo, or festering in a classroom in Lagos or Lahore and have seen gruesome images generated by the wars we are prosecuting in Muslim lands. Perhaps “their” anger is combined with the angst generated by globalized economic forces “they” cannot understand. In some cases, those same forces may have rendered irrelevant their lives and their religion, the two sources of meaning in the world “they” thought “they” had inherited from “their” forefathers. Under such circumstances, “they” are easy prey to skilled recruiters who promise “them” both meaning and a free pass to Paradise by encouraging “them” to mindlessly strike out at what “they” are led to believe is the source of “their” misery.
Finally, “they” may be ignorant of both the deeper currents of world affairs and the deeper meanings of “their” religion. “they” probably have no idea of just how inconsequential spectacular violence is to the advancement of their cause. “they” probably have never stopped to reflect on how that violence is used by neo-fascist pundits and politicians to advance a climate of fear and misunderstanding that makes it more likely that even ordinarily well-meaning Americans will support policies that will lead to more bombing, maiming and murdering of Muslims –and eventually others- all around the globe. For this small minority, “their” obsession with Islam as a political ideology probably renders “them” totally oblivious to the religious message of Islam as an historical world religion that advances the sanctity of life, especially the life of innocent, noncombatant peoples, the refinement of the spirit and patient, dignified, principled resistance when confronted with the savage vagaries of “their” fellow humans.
Comments (37)
ahmad as soomaali
April 17, 2010
Much love to you Sheikh Zaid Shakir. I appreciate your inside and deep thoughts on the happenings of our times.
Jason
April 21, 2010
Very well written
Lynn
April 23, 2010
I saw a 2008 comment over on "nicedeb" http://nicedeb.wordpress.com/about/ linked to this site, and this was my response: To the "Muslim Next Door," not all Catholics are bad or evil. My Carmelite president, about a week after 9/11 tells how she was going up the driveway to a garage sale, and a Muslim-looking woman was coming down. Ordinarily she wouldn't have thought to do it, but since she figured Muslims would be experiencing bad treatment after 9/11, she decided to give the woman a smile, which she did. The woman gave her back a very big smile. That is our Carmelite, Catholic way. Just to be good in the world. To do little deeds of goodness. I know how much Muslims have suffered in this country. Even people who are not Muslim, if they look like Muslims get the bad treatment. Right after 9/11 some hot-headed Anglos got out their guns and shot and killed some Sikhs (who wear the distinctive turbins), not even realizing Sikhism is a very different religion. It's just that they looked more Muslim than the Muslims. Also an Hispanic man with a moustache was confronted by a policeman who warned him, after finding out he was only an Hispanic -- "I'd lose the moustache." We are an evil people, who nearly invented germ warfare and genocide against Native Americans. We have no right at all to consider other people bad or evil, beyond what we are. That's the pot calling the kettle black. I wish we could look at our own sins and as Muslims do, struggle inwardly against them -- the true meaning of jihad.
Kevin Cares
June 15, 2010
Good day, I'm a christian, yet I'm not in favor of the war or conflict between islam & christian... that issue start so many decades ago, but until now this rival never ends. We can start the peace in ourselves, we can live a better & peaceful life by not getting involve... there are so many innocent lives that are harmed between that rivals, specially our little ones & mother earth... lets save! [url=http://www.octief.com.au]Asbestos Testing Lab[/url] [url=http://www.octief.com.au]Asbestos Certification[/url]
registry cleaner reviews
August 5, 2010
Very good journey and experience!
business finance software
August 11, 2010
good share, great article, very usefull for us...thank you
investment earnings
August 13, 2010
This guy is really lucky !
investment earnings
August 13, 2010
great share, great article, very usefull for me...thank you
contraceptive methods
August 29, 2010
Nice article. Thank you for this info
contraceptive methods
August 29, 2010
Great article Thank you so much!
home mortgage rate
August 29, 2010
Thank you for sharing I wish I could go somwhere.
home mortgage rate
August 29, 2010
Really nice and impressive blog i found today.
acai diet pills
November 27, 2010
Soon Information,street strong safe new internal study author wall working assumption record aye competition obtain couple survey crime child industry existing eat senior implication director lose software photograph gas tape already relief bed other this want useful freedom newspaper initiative course car commission tour notice limited strong male citizen concern concentrate direct forget speak handle revenue cut organise phase troop equal status perhaps award lead spirit guide seat process prime summer possibly encourage introduction set charge she damage feel current money know both profit spend substantial scale sample
TymnTauhanync
March 25, 2011
Very Interesting Information! Thank You For Thi Blog!
wisconsin police car impounds
April 6, 2011
Great Post. I add this Blog to my bookmarks.
sdfsdgfd
April 20, 2011
I find myself coming to your blog more and more often to the point where my visits are almost daily now!
Gert
April 25, 2011
BION I'm irpemssed! Cool post!
affordable auto insurance
June 17, 2011
Generally I don't read post on blogs, but I would like to say that this write-up very forced me to check out and do it! Your writing style has been surprised me. Thanks, very great post. low cost auto insurance
affordable auto insurance
July 7, 2011
Its like you read my mind! You seem to know so much approximately this, such as you wrote the ebook in it or something. I feel that you simply can do with some percent to pressure the message home a little bit, but other than that, this is magnificent blog. A fantastic read. I'll certainly be back. affordable car insurance affordable car insurance
auto insurance comparison
July 15, 2011
Hi there, I found your website via Google while looking for a similar topic, your website came up, it appears good. I've bookmarked it in my google bookmarks. compare auto insurance compare auto insurance quote compare auto insurance rates
buy edu backlinks
July 20, 2011
Hello there, I discovered your blog via Google whilst searching for a related matter, your web site got here up, it appears to be like good. I have bookmarked it in my google bookmarks. buy edu backlinks
cheap michigan auto insurance
July 29, 2011
Helpful info. Lucky me I found your site by chance, and I am surprised why this twist of fate didn't happened in advance! I bookmarked it. cheap michigan auto insurance
tour russia
January 27, 2012
I do not even know with strong your blog greatly that helped me. Thank you “That is the saving grace of humor. If you fail no one is laughing at you.” - A. Whitney Brown
russia tours
January 30, 2012
I do not even know with incredibly blog greatly that helped me. God bless you “Analyzing humor is like dissecting a frog. Few people are interested and the frog dies of it.” - E.B. White
Alexa
February 10, 2012
Superior site. Nice posting comments system. My apologies for the off-topic write-up, nevertheless I had been quite impressed with Djokovic's play in the final of the Australia OPen this year. The man is definitely unbeatable. He showed he had been as strong as metal. Simply imagine about he he can beat Nadal who was so stimulated to win as well as was really so motivated up during the 5th set. Now i'm commencing to believe that Djokovic is performing some religious work to bring some forces on his side which help him win these kinds of matches up against the very best players in the planet order a research paper . Any idea what concerning Rafa's game?
My Writing Service
February 11, 2012
That is some very good stuff published right here. I thank you for excellent information. I 'm writing a research paper about national politics and your website helped a whole lot. I'm a school student so if you're in a insufficient time I suggest to get support intended for Essay Writing . Cheers!
Motivation to lose weight
April 7, 2012
dqVWcw A big thank you for your article.Really looking forward to read more. Much obliged.
Motivation to lose weight
April 9, 2012
5LiUQU Im obliged for the blog article. Want more.
Dissertation Coaching
April 16, 2012
Your pictures are the best. I really like the article content, it gets your online visitors tied to your weblog. I'm a undergraduate and i'm now bombarded with term papers, dissertation writing approved by turnitin research papers, book reports essays papers and other challenges. I truly want to generate my own essays however some aid is often desired. I intend to work with solidwriters.com for my final buy dissertation task . I discovered them by google . Can keep you posted on the success.
TimurDumb
April 17, 2012
I must say thanks to you with respect to your weblog. You've got a great deal of attention-grabbing content hence the site is great. I'm a college student in The state of california and I have an crucial school assignment due immediately. I am just jammed as well as have writers-block at the moment as I am researching. Need anybody to aid me revise the cost-free article I discovered on line internet essay . That report satisfies my specifications yet is written in an undesirable style and there are grammar errors. Do you think I ought to proceed? Now i'm simply just in need of help, so any recommendation could be wonderful.
Dewie
April 23, 2012
I have visited this weitsbe for the first time. You will notice that the publisher has used a grey background for a black print. There is a strain on the eyes to read as the background and the print almost seem to merge. I have been unable to read the matter. And there are probably many who might just leave the weitsbe and not bother to comment. Please look into this and do the needful. JazakAllah Khair.VA:F [1.9.7_1111]please wait...VA:F [1.9.7_1111](from 0 votes)
patio cleaning
June 30, 2012
some very interesting thoughts, please do keep writing and exposing the truth.
paul
March 13, 2017
wow very nice That Gent Mark
Jospeh31
March 15, 2018
We must nothing but look in support of several specialised examples online. There is a enormous numbers of divergent advantageous info on the web learn to create the resource composition nowadays really. I can also recommend you to judge out. It is a diminish predilection indeed.
Michel15
March 16, 2018
You must nothing but look instead of several specialised guides online. There is a lot of unalike useful info on the cobweb article 244 these days really. I can also second you to try one\'s hand at out. It is a cool emotional attachment indeed.
Russ58
March 20, 2018
You can nothing but look for several specialised guides online. There is a oceans of different advantageous info on the network biotech stiff faces a record trio these days really. I can also second you to try not at home. It is a chilliness thing indeed.
Harris Alejandro
July 25, 2020
I have actually read your article, as well as must have the capacity to point out - this particular is a real gem. The last time I have actually show up across one thing likewise well-written was https://xfreeslots.com/slot/. Your component is actually definitely an excellent read, thanks. Wish you the large target market besides motivation for a lot more articles.
More Notes
On The Passing of Lindsey Graham
Imam Zaid Shakir · July 12, 2026
“It is not the least ironic that Lindsey Graham should pass away at a time the country is celebrating its 250th anniversary. Graham represented the genocidal impulse that has stained American history. As Americans we do not like discussing the fact…
Note
The American/Israeli War on Iran: Part One
Imam Zaid Shakir · April 22, 2026
The savage, unprovoked American/Israeli attack on Iran illustrates an old play, as far as the American side is concerned. It is amazing that the same script is rolled out for each violent, imperialist episode, yet there are still people who line up…
Note
Imam Jamil, Imam Talib: Two Mountains
Imam Zaid Shakir · January 11, 2026
Owing to a very difficult and challenging couple of months, I was unable to sit down and share my thoughts on the passing of two giants who impacted me and many others in profound ways. Those two giants are Imam Jamil al-Amin and Imam Talib Abdul…
Note